A Payments Company's Hard Call: Absorb 0.5% Interchange or Lose 12,000 Merchants
Archi4 min read
Contents
The Decision That Landed on One Desk#
In late 2024, a card network notified acquirers of a small change to its interchange schedule: certain small-ticket debit transactions would carry a higher rate, effective the following quarter. For most processors, the notice was a line item. For one mid-sized acquirer that handles primarily coffee shops, convenience stores, and food trucks, it was a direct hit. The company had roughly 12,000 merchants, and about 40% of its volume sat in the ticket range the network was repricing.
The CEO had three options. Pass the increase to merchants. Absorb it and cut margin. Or renegotiate contracts, which for small merchants meant sending notices and risking churn.
She chose to absorb it for twelve months. The company later described the decision to investors as a retention move. The numbers behind that choice are more interesting than the press release.
Why Absorbing Looked Cheaper Than Passing It On#
The company's average merchant processed about $9,000 a month in card volume. At a 0.5% increase, that is $45 per merchant per month, or $540 a year. For a food truck operator clearing $6,000 in a slow month, a surprise fee change is a reason to call a competitor. The acquirer's own churn data showed that merchants who saw an unannounced rate change were roughly twice as likely to leave within six months.
Losing 10% of 12,000 merchants at an average revenue per merchant of about $250 a month would cost $3.6 million in annualized revenue. The full cost of absorbing the increase across the affected volume was closer to $2.1 million. On a spreadsheet, absorption wins.
That is the standard defense of the decision, and it is correct as far as it goes. But it treats the fee increase as a one-time event. It was not.
The Part the Spreadsheet Missed#
Card network pricing is not static. Acquirers receive notices two to four times a year, and the direction is rarely down. The company had already absorbed a smaller increase in 2022. Each time, the absorption calculation looked similar, and each time the absorption cost grew because the merchant base and the volume had grown with it.
By the end of 2025, the company's net revenue per merchant had fallen by an estimated 4% to 6% compared with two years earlier, while its merchant count had grown. The growth masked the margin problem in the top line. It did not fix it.
This is the core trade in payments: scale buys time, but it does not change the direction of the cost curve. A processor that absorbs fee increases trains its sales team to sell on price and its merchants to expect stability. Both are expensive habits.
What the Alternative Would Have Cost#
Passing the increase through is not free either. The company would have needed to send contract amendments, update statements, and staff a call center for merchants asking why their bill changed. Industry benchmarks for a fee-change communication put the fully loaded cost at roughly $8 to $15 per merchant, which on 5,000 affected merchants is $40,000 to $75,000. That is small compared with $2.1 million.
The real cost of passing it through is churn, and churn is hardest to predict at the low end of the market. A 5% attrition rate among affected merchants would have cost about $1.5 million in annualized revenue. A 10% rate would have cost $3 million. Absorption only wins if the churn rate stays below roughly 7%.
That threshold is the number the board should have been staring at. It is close enough to the observed churn that a single bad quarter could flip the decision.
The Bet I Would Have Argued For#
Absorbing was defensible for one quarter. Absorbing for twelve months without a plan to reset pricing was a mistake. The company should have split the difference: absorb the first increase, then use the twelve months to move merchants to a pricing structure that indexes to network costs, with clear notice and a small loyalty credit for merchants who stay.
That approach keeps the retention benefit and removes the recurring surprise. It also forces the sales team to talk about total cost rather than a headline rate, which is a healthier conversation.
Payments companies that survive multiple network repricing cycles tend to do one thing consistently: they make the cost of card acceptance visible to merchants and give them tools to manage it. Those that hide it are borrowing against future churn.
The company here bought a year of goodwill for $2.1 million. The next notice arrives in a few months. Whether that year was a bridge or a delay depends on what pricing changes ship before then.
More articles