App Stores Face a Regulatory Reckoning: What Happens Next

Archi4 min read

regulationmobileantitrustappstores

Contents
  1. The App Store Monopoly Is Ending. Slowly.
  2. The European Union Sets the Pace
  3. The United States Follows a Different Path
  4. The UK and Japan Add Pressure
  5. What Regulators Will Do Next
  6. The Cost for Developers
  7. What to Watch

The App Store Monopoly Is Ending. Slowly.#

For a decade, Apple and Google have operated as the gatekeepers of the mobile app economy. That era is closing. Regulators in Brussels, Washington, and London have moved from investigation to enforcement. The question is no longer whether app stores will face new rules, but how fast those rules will arrive and what they will cost developers and users.

The European Union Sets the Pace#

The Digital Markets Act (DMA) is the most concrete force. Since March 2024, Apple has been required to allow alternative app marketplaces and sideloading on iPhones in the EU. Google faces similar obligations for Android. The early results are instructive: Apple introduced a new fee structure (50 euro cents per install after one million downloads) that critics call a poison pill. Expect the European Commission to challenge such fees in the coming months.

By late 2025, the Commission is likely to open formal proceedings against Apple for non-compliance with the DMA's anti-steering rules, which prevent developers from pointing users to cheaper payment options outside the app. The fine could reach 10 percent of global revenue, or 20 percent for repeat offenses. Apple will appeal, but the legal pressure will not disappear.

The United States Follows a Different Path#

The US has no DMA equivalent. Instead, the Department of Justice's antitrust case against Apple, filed in March 2024, targets the company's control over app distribution and in-app payments. A trial is expected in 2026. The remedies, if the DOJ wins, could include forcing Apple to allow third-party app stores and payment systems nationwide.

Meanwhile, state legislatures are moving faster. Ohio and North Carolina have introduced bills that would require app stores to permit alternative payment methods. These bills are modeled on the Open App Markets Act, which failed in Congress but has bipartisan support in several states. Watch for at least two states to pass such laws by the end of 2025, triggering immediate court challenges from Apple and Google.

The UK and Japan Add Pressure#

The UK's Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act, passed in 2024, gives the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) power to designate Apple and Google as having "strategic market status." That designation, expected in 2025, would allow the CMA to impose conduct requirements, including opening up app store payments and distribution. The CMA has signaled it will act quickly.

Japan passed its own smartphone software law in 2024, requiring app stores to allow alternative payment systems and app marketplaces by 2025. The Japan Fair Trade Commission will start enforcement in late 2025. Companies that fail to comply face fines of up to 6 percent of domestic revenue.

What Regulators Will Do Next#

Based on the trajectory, here is a forecast of specific actions in the next 18 months:

  1. The EU will fine Apple for DMA non-compliance. The Commission is already investigating Apple's new fee structure. A fine in the hundreds of millions of euros is likely by mid-2025, with a final decision by early 2026.
  2. The DOJ will seek structural remedies. The antitrust trial will focus on Apple's control of app distribution. If the DOJ wins, the court could order Apple to allow third-party app stores and sideloading across the US, not just in the EU.
  3. State laws will create a patchwork. At least three states will pass app store openness laws by the end of 2025. Apple and Google will sue to block them, but the legal uncertainty will force them to adjust policies nationally to avoid a fragmented market.
  4. The UK will impose conduct requirements. The CMA will likely require Apple and Google to allow alternative payment systems and provide developers with more data about app performance. Enforcement will begin in 2026.
  5. Japan will enforce its new law. The JFTC will start with warnings but will escalate to fines if app stores do not comply by late 2025.

The Cost for Developers#

Compliance will not be free. Apple's new fee structure in the EU, for example, charges developers 50 euro cents per install after one million downloads. For a popular app with 10 million downloads, that is 4.5 million euros per year. Smaller developers will feel less pain, but the uncertainty will complicate budgeting.

Alternative payment systems will also bring new costs. Payment processors typically charge 2 to 3 percent per transaction, compared to Apple's 15 to 30 percent commission. That looks like a saving, but developers will need to handle fraud, chargebacks, and customer support themselves. For many, the net gain will be smaller than expected.

What to Watch#

The next 18 months will be defined by legal battles, not sudden changes. The EU will lead, the US will follow slowly, and other countries will fill the gaps. Developers should prepare for a world where app distribution is no longer a single gatekeeper but a patchwork of rules and fees. The winners will be those who read the fine print early and build flexible billing systems.

The app store monopoly is not dead, but it is bleeding. Regulators have the knives out, and they are not putting them away.

More articles