Five Years of Linux on the Desktop: Notes from a Week of Testing

Archi4 min read

linuxoperating-systemshardwaretesting

Contents
  1. The same laptop, five years apart
  2. Install and first boot
  3. Hardware support: the quiet wins
  4. Software: flatpaks everywhere, for better and worse
  5. What still hurts
  6. The honest comparison

The same laptop, five years apart#

The test machine is a 2019 ThinkPad T480, 16GB of RAM, an Intel i5-8250U, and a 256GB SSD. In early 2020 I installed Ubuntu 20.04 on it and wrote down everything that annoyed me. This month I wiped the disk and installed a current release, then spent a week doing normal work: video calls, a browser with 30 tabs, a Python project, printing, and a couple of external monitors over USB-C.

The point was not to crown a winner. It was to check how much of the old friction is gone and how much is just hidden better.

Install and first boot#

In 2020 the installer finished in about 25 minutes and asked me to pick a keyboard layout twice. This year the whole thing took 11 minutes, including a reboot. The installer detected the fingerprint reader, offered full disk encryption with one checkbox, and set up a swap file sized to my RAM without asking.

First boot landed on a working desktop with Wi-Fi connected, Bluetooth on, and the correct screen resolution. Five years ago I remember editing a GRUB line to stop the backlight from flickering at login. That class of fix is mostly gone. Mostly.

Hardware support: the quiet wins#

Suspend and resume that used to lose the Wi-Fi connection now come back clean. The fingerprint reader, which required a vendor driver and a firmware update in 2020, worked out of the box after a login. External monitors over a single USB-C cable, including daisy-chained DisplayPort, came up at the right resolution and refresh rate on the first try.

Audio is still the weak spot. The internal mic worked, but my USB interface needed a sample rate change in the settings panel before it would record without crackle. That is a 30 second fix, but it is a fix I did not have to do on the same machine five years ago because I simply never got the interface working then.

Battery life is the number I care about most. With the same workload (browser, editor, a few terminals), the 2020 install idled around 9 watts and gave me about four hours. The current install idles near 6 watts and gets close to six hours. Some of that is kernel scheduling work, some is the newer browser, and some is the fact that I am no longer running a compositor with every effect turned on.

Software: flatpaks everywhere, for better and worse#

Package management is where the gap is widest. Five years ago, installing a recent version of a desktop app meant adding a third-party repository and hoping the signing keys held up. Now most of what I use ships as a Flatpak or a Snap, installs in one command, and updates itself in the background.

The tradeoff is disk space. du -sh on my app directory shows 6.4GB, and three apps each bundle their own copy of the same runtime. Five years ago the same set of programs took under 2GB. Sandboxing is real protection, and I would not give it up, but the storage bill is not zero.

Wayland is now the default session, and that changed my workflow in small ways. Screen sharing in video calls works, but only after I approved a portal prompt the first time. Global hotkeys for my clipboard manager needed a config change. On the plus side, mixed refresh rate monitors no longer tear, and fractional scaling on a 1440p panel looks sharp instead of blurry. That alone would have sold me in 2020.

What still hurts#

The printer. A network laser printer that worked without complaint in 2020 needed a manual driver selection this time, and the duplex setting reset after every job. Printing remains the one task where I still expect to lose 20 minutes.

Firmware updates are better but uneven. The built-in updater found a BIOS update and a dock firmware update, applied both, and asked for a reboot. It did not offer the SSD firmware, which I had to flash from a vendor tool. Five years ago none of this existed in the OS at all, so progress is clear, but the coverage is inconsistent across vendors.

Recovery is unchanged. When I deliberately broke the bootloader to test it, I still needed a live USB and a chroot to repair it. The graphical rescue tools have improved, but the fallback is the same terminal commands I typed in 2020.

The honest comparison#

The list of things that broke my day in 2020 was long: Wi-Fi drops, suspend failures, scaling artifacts, driver hunts, and a package manager that fought me on versions. This week that list was three items: printer duplex, one audio device, and SSD firmware. The install is faster, the hardware support is broader, and the defaults are smarter.

The remaining gaps are narrower but not trivial. They cluster around peripherals and recovery, the places where a desktop OS has to cooperate with hardware it does not control. Five years of work closed most of the everyday friction. The last stretch is the part that only shows up when something goes wrong, and that is exactly where a normal user has the least patience.

More articles