Free with Ads, One-Time Purchase, or Subscription: A Weather App's Three Ways to Earn

Archi4 min read

monetizationappssubscriptionsads

Contents
  1. The Three Ways a Simple App Can Pay
  2. Free with Ads
  3. One-Time Purchase
  4. Subscription
  5. The Money Difference

The Three Ways a Simple App Can Pay#

A weather app with 100,000 downloads can generate less than a minimum wage, a single lump sum, or a steady monthly check. The difference is not the forecast. It is the payment model locked in before the first line of code.

For this comparison, assume a real app called Clear Sky with 100,000 lifetime installs and 20,000 people who open it each month. The developer pays 20 dollars per month for a weather data API and 10 dollars for hosting. The app is already built. The only open question is how it charges.

Free with Ads#

The app shows one banner and one interstitial per user per day. With 20,000 daily actives, that is 20,000 banner requests and 20,000 interstitial requests per day, or 1.2 million ad requests per month.

Most ad networks pay per thousand impressions, or eCPM. A weather app in the United States and Western Europe might see an average eCPM of 6 dollars. Fill rate, the share of requests that actually return an ad, is around 85 percent. That works out to 1.02 million paid impressions per month. At 6 dollars per thousand, gross revenue is 6,120 dollars.

The ad network takes 25 percent. The developer receives 4,590 dollars. There is no App Store commission on ad revenue, but the App Store charges the developer 99 dollars per year for a developer account, and Google Play charges 25 dollars one time. The developer also pays for an ad mediation tool, 50 dollars per month, to manage three different networks.

Net from ads: about 4,490 dollars per month. That money stays steady as long as people open the app. It drops in December, when eCPM falls, and rises in March, when advertisers spend more.

One-Time Purchase#

The second way is to remove ads and charge 4.99 dollars in the App Store and on Google Play. Most store customers pay this once and expect every future update to be included.

Conversion rates for a paid utility app are not cheerful. Of 100,000 installs, maybe 2 percent become paying customers. That is 2,000 sales. Both stores take 15 percent from developers earning under one million dollars per year, so the developer keeps 4.24 dollars per sale. Total revenue is 8,480 dollars.

The hosting and API costs remain 30 dollars per month. If the developer pays a designer for a one-time icon refresh, that is another 400 dollars. After two years of updates and support, the one-time price has brought in less than the ad model brought in during a single month.

The advantage is simplicity. There are no monthly metrics, no ad SDKs, no privacy labels for tracking. The disadvantage is that revenue ends on the day the last copy sells.

Subscription#

The third path is a subscription. Clear Sky offers 2.99 dollars per month or 19.99 dollars per year, with a seven-day free trial. Of the 20,000 monthly active users, 3 percent subscribe. That is 600 subscribers. Half choose the annual plan, half choose monthly.

Annual revenue from 300 subscribers is 5,997 dollars. Monthly revenue from 300 subscribers is 897 dollars per month. The monthly equivalent of annual revenue is 499 dollars per month, so total monthly recognized revenue is 1,396 dollars. After the 15 percent store commission, the developer keeps 1,187 dollars per month.

Subscription revenue does not sit still. A 5 percent monthly churn rate removes 30 subscribers every month. That means the developer must add 30 new paying subscribers each month just to stay at 600. At a 3 percent conversion rate, that requires 1,000 new monthly users. The app receives maybe 2,000 new installs per month through search and word of mouth, so growth is possible, but every feature update becomes a race to reduce churn.

A subscription also carries a second cost: the store's billing platform. Apple and Google charge the same 15 percent, but refunds and chargebacks eat another 2 percent on average. Customer support questions about "how do I cancel" arrive daily. If the developer spends 20 minutes per day answering those emails, that is 10 hours per month of unpaid labor.

The Money Difference#

After one year, the ad model produces about 53,880 dollars. The one-time purchase produces 8,480 dollars, at best. The subscription produces 14,244 dollars in the first year, assuming 3 percent conversion, 5 percent monthly churn, and no growth in active users.

The ad model wins on raw revenue for a simple weather app. It loses on user trust: half the users complain about battery drain and data use. The subscription wins on renewals. If the developer adds a radar layer that paid users can access, monthly churn drops to 2 percent, and year-two subscription revenue rises above 35,000 dollars.

The one-time purchase wins on ethics, not arithmetic. A customer pays once and owes nothing. But that model cannot fund a small team. The decision comes down to what the developer wants: a monthly check from advertisers, a single check from consumers, or a growing check from subscribers who must be earned again every month.

More articles