MPLS vs. SD-WAN vs. Internet: The Real Cost of Connecting 50 Branch Offices

Archi4 min read

networkingtelecomcostssd-wan

Contents
  1. The Bill That Arrives Every Month
  2. The MPLS Quote
  3. The SD-WAN Quote
  4. The Internet-Only Quote
  5. Where the Numbers Converge
  6. The Break-Even Point
  7. The Line Items Vendors Leave Out
  8. What to Do With the Quote

The Bill That Arrives Every Month#

A 50-branch retailer needs to move data between stores and a data center. Three options sit on the table: keep MPLS, move to SD-WAN, or run everything over business internet with a VPN. The sticker prices look far apart. The total costs are closer than vendors admit, and the difference usually comes down to one line item: what you pay when something breaks.

The MPLS Quote#

MPLS is sold per site, per megabit, with a service level agreement attached. A typical 20 Mbps MPLS circuit at a branch runs $500 to $900 a month, depending on distance from the carrier's nearest point of presence. Fifty sites at $700 average is $35,000 a month, or $420,000 a year. Add a managed router fee of $50 to $100 per site and the annual total lands near $450,000.

That price buys predictable latency, a committed rate, and a phone number to call at 2 a.m. It does not buy bandwidth. Upgrading to 100 Mbps at every site can triple the bill, which is why many MPLS networks still run 10 or 20 Mbps circuits in 2024.

The SD-WAN Quote#

SD-WAN is not a circuit. It is an overlay that sits on top of whatever circuits you buy. Vendors quote three numbers: the appliance or virtual instance per site, the orchestration subscription, and the underlying transport.

A midrange SD-WAN appliance at 50 sites costs roughly $1,000 to $2,500 each, or $50,000 to $125,000 up front. Subscription fees run $50 to $150 per site per month, so $30,000 to $90,000 a year. Transport is where the savings appear: two business internet links at $150 each instead of one MPLS circuit at $700. That cuts transport from $420,000 to $180,000 a year.

The catch is staffing. SD-WAN shifts configuration and troubleshooting onto your own team or a managed service provider. A managed SD-WAN contract often costs $300 to $500 per site per month, which erases much of the transport savings at small sites.

The Internet-Only Quote#

A VPN over two business internet connections is the cheapest option on paper. Fifty sites at $300 a month for a primary and backup link is $180,000 a year. Add a few firewalls and a VPN concentrator and the capital cost stays under $150,000.

The hidden cost is outage exposure. Consumer-grade internet at a strip mall has no committed repair window. A cut line can take a day or more to fix. For a store that processes card payments, a four-hour outage on a Saturday can cost more in lost sales than a year of MPLS premium at that site. The math only works if the business can tolerate downtime or has a cellular failover that actually works.

Where the Numbers Converge#

Run the three scenarios over five years, including hardware refresh and circuit installation: , MPLS: about $2.25 million, with installation and managed router fees front-loaded., Managed SD-WAN: about $1.8 million, depending on the per-site contract terms., Do-it-yourself SD-WAN: about $1.4 million, plus the cost of the engineers who run it., Internet only with VPN: about $1.1 million, plus outage risk.

The gap between MPLS and DIY SD-WAN is real but smaller than the transport savings suggest. Installation charges, early termination fees on existing MPLS contracts, and the salary of one network engineer (roughly $120,000 fully loaded) eat into the difference.

The Break-Even Point#

A 50-site network typically breaks even on SD-WAN somewhere between 18 and 30 months, assuming the company keeps at least one MPLS circuit at its data center and does not need to renegotiate an existing contract. Below 20 sites, the per-site subscription and appliance costs often make MPLS cheaper. Above 100 sites, the transport savings dominate and SD-WAN wins on cost almost every time.

The Line Items Vendors Leave Out#

Ask for these before signing: , Installation and activation. MPLS installation can run $500 to $2,000 per site. SD-WAN appliance shipping and staging adds $200 to $500 per site., Early termination. Most MPLS contracts run three years with penalties of 50 percent of remaining charges. Check the exit number before comparing monthly rates., Support tiers. A 24/7 support contract on SD-WAN can add 20 percent to the subscription., Cellular failover. A usable LTE backup runs $50 to $100 per site per month, plus data charges. It is the cheapest insurance against a cut line and the first thing cut from a tight budget., Circuit diversity. Two internet links from the same carrier often share a conduit. Paying for a second provider is the only way to get real redundancy, and it usually adds $100 to $200 per site.

What to Do With the Quote#

Get the five-year total cost, not the monthly rate. Include the cost of the engineer who will run the thing. Model one outage scenario at your busiest site and see whether the savings survive it. The cheapest network is the one whose failure mode your business can actually absorb.

More articles