Nine Taps to Change One Setting: Notes From a Week of App Testing
Archi4 min read
Contents
The number that stopped me: nine#
I spent last week with 22 apps installed on a clean Android phone and a two year old iPhone, logging every screen I had to open to reach one ordinary setting. Not onboarding. Not account creation. Just the privacy and notification switches a person might reasonably want to check twice a year.
The median count was nine taps. The worst was a personal finance app at 14. The best was a weather app at three, and it got there by putting the switch on the main settings screen, which is apparently allowed.
I counted taps, not seconds, because taps survive redesigns and screen sizes. A tap is a decision. Nine of them, with four of those behind submenus with names I had to guess, is a small tax paid every time.
How I counted#
, Each app freshly installed, no data restored from backup., I searched for the switch by name first, then by navigation only if search failed., A tap on a list item counted. A scroll did not. A back gesture did., I ran every path twice, on both phones, and used the lower number.
Two of the 22 apps hid notification controls in a web view that opened a browser tab. Those got a separate note, not a tap count, because the counting stops making sense once you leave the app.
What the distribution looked like#
Eleven apps sat between seven and eleven taps. Five were under six. Six were above twelve. The cluster is the story, not the outliers: nine taps is not one bad designer, it is a convention.
The pattern was consistent too. Settings menus have grown four or five categories deep, and privacy items get split across them. One app kept "Location" under Permissions, "Ad personalization" under About, and "Data sharing" under Legal. Three different top level categories for three switches that belong on one screen.
Search helped in eight apps. In three, searching "privacy" returned nothing, though the setting existed. In one, search returned a help article about privacy rather than the switch itself, which is a special kind of joke.
The submenu names#
A short list of labels I had to tap through to find things: Advanced, More, General, Preferences, About, Legal, Privacy Center, Account Tools. The label "Advanced" held the notification switch in two apps, which tells you nothing about what is inside.
Where the taps actually go#
I broke the 14 tap path down. Three taps to open the profile tab, two to reach settings, two to enter a submenu, four to scroll a list and pick the right item, one to open the switch, one to confirm, one to dismiss a prompt asking me to enable notifications instead.
That last one appeared in 15 of 22 apps. The moment you turn notifications down, something asks you to turn them up. It is a dialog, and dialogs take a tap to close, so the honest cost of the setting is usually one more than the count.
Dark patterns get most of the attention. This was quieter: friction applied evenly, no malice visible, just a settings tree that grew one feature at a time and never got pruned.
The apps that did it well#
Three apps put the main privacy switches on the first settings screen with plain labels. One showed the current state in the list itself, so I could read all six switches without opening any of them. That is the design I would copy: state visible, one tap to change, no confirmation dialog for a switch that is trivially reversible.
A meditation app had the best flow. Settings, Privacy, six switches, done. Four taps including opening settings. It also had a line of text saying what each switch did, which took no extra taps at all.
The worst flow was not the 14 tap app. It was a shopping app that required me to open a support chat to opt out of marketing email. I did not complete that path. I am counting it as a failure rather than a number.
A note on confirmations#
Five apps asked me to confirm disabling a setting. Two asked twice. Confirmations make sense for deletion. For a notification toggle, they are a speed bump with a friendly face.
What nine taps is worth#
At roughly 1.5 seconds per tap including load time, nine taps is under 15 seconds. Nobody is defeated by 15 seconds once. The cost shows up in repetition and in the settings people never check because the path is annoying.
Run the math on a yearly privacy review across 40 apps at nine taps each. That is 360 taps and something close to nine minutes, plus the guessing time, which I did not count and which is the real expense. My rough log had 41 wrong turns across the week, each one a back gesture and a second try.
Small teams can fix this in an afternoon. Put the switches that matter on one screen. Label them in plain words. Show the state without opening anything. Skip the confirmation. My test phone now has six fewer apps on it, and the settings I did change are the ones I could find.
More articles