The 61% Myth: Why Most Breach Victims Never Tell Their Customers
Archi5 min read
Contents
The 61% Myth: Why Most Breach Victims Never Tell Their Customers#
In 2023, a survey of 1,200 security leaders found that 61% of companies that suffered a data breach never told their customers. The number went viral. It was cited in boardrooms, in regulatory filings, and in at least three congressional hearings. It is also almost certainly wrong.
The survey was conducted by a mid-sized security vendor and relied on self-reported answers. Self-reported breach data is notoriously unreliable. The same methodology, applied to other questions, suggests that roughly 30% of respondents would lie about lying. The 61% figure is not a measure of silence. It is a measure of how many security leaders are willing to admit, on a form, that their company failed.
Still, the myth persists because it feels true. Breaches happen. Companies stay quiet. Small customers get hurt. The problem is that the real number, the one that would actually help policymakers, is buried under a different set of statistics that nobody wants to talk about.
Myth: Companies hide breaches because they can#
Fact: In most jurisdictions, companies hide breaches because the rules give them room to. The GDPR requires disclosure within 72 hours, but only if the breach is "likely to result in a risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons." That phrase is doing a lot of work. A company can argue, in good faith, that a leaked database of hashed passwords does not meet that threshold. A regulator might disagree, but the regulator has to find out first.
In the United States, disclosure is a patchwork. All 50 states have breach notification laws, but the thresholds vary. Some require notification only if the breached data includes a name plus a Social Security number or a financial account. A leaked list of email addresses and hashed passwords might not trigger a requirement in 14 states. A company operating nationally can follow the weakest standard and still be technically compliant.
The 61% figure conflates two different things: breaches that were not disclosed because the company broke the law, and breaches that were not disclosed because the law allowed it. The first group is small. The second group is large, and it is the one that matters.
Myth: Customers never find out#
Fact: Customers find out all the time, just not from the company. They find out when their password shows up in a credential-stuffing attack. They find out when a friend forwards a screenshot of a dark web forum. They find out when their bank calls them about a suspicious charge.
The average time between a breach and a customer discovering it on their own is roughly 11 months. That number comes from incident response firms that track credential reuse. It is not a precise figure, but it is directionally correct. The point is that the disclosure clock and the discovery clock are not the same. A company can follow the letter of the law and still leave its customers exposed for nearly a year.
This is where the surprising number comes in. When researchers look at breaches that were disclosed voluntarily, not because of a legal requirement, the median time to disclosure is 34 days. When they look at breaches that were disclosed because of a legal requirement, the median time is 71 days. The voluntary disclosures were faster. The companies that chose to speak did so sooner than the companies that were forced to.
That finding cuts against the myth. It suggests that the problem is not a lack of willingness to disclose. It is a lack of clarity about what to disclose and when. Companies that have a plan disclose faster. Companies that do not have a plan wait for a lawyer to tell them what to do.
Myth: The 61% is the number to fix#
Fact: The number to fix is 11 months. If a company can detect a breach and notify customers within 30 days, the damage from credential reuse drops by more than half. That is the finding from a 2024 analysis of 400 breach notifications. The analysis controlled for the size of the breach and the type of data. The variable that mattered most was time.
The 61% figure is a distraction. It is easy to cite and hard to verify. It invites arguments about whether the survey was representative, whether the respondents were honest, and whether the question was worded correctly. Those arguments are not useful. They do not help a small business decide whether to notify its customers. They do not help a regulator decide whether to open an investigation.
The useful questions are different. Did the company have a disclosure plan before the breach? Did the plan specify who decides? Did it include a timeline? Did it account for the fact that the legal threshold might be ambiguous?
Companies that answer yes to those questions disclose faster. Companies that answer no wait. The waiting is what hurts customers. The 61% is just a story we tell to explain the waiting. It is not the cause.
What actually happens after a breach#
A breach is not a single event. It is a sequence of decisions. The first decision is whether to notify. The second is what to say. The third is what to do for the people affected.
Most companies get the first decision wrong because they treat it as a legal question. It is not. It is an operational question. The legal question is whether the company is required to notify. The operational question is whether the company can afford to wait. Waiting costs money. It costs customer trust. It costs regulatory goodwill. It costs the time of the incident response team, which has to keep the breach quiet while the lawyers argue.
The 61% myth persists because it lets companies off the hook. If most companies hide breaches, then hiding is normal. If hiding is normal, then a company that hides is not doing anything wrong. It is just doing what everyone else does.
The reality is that most companies do not hide breaches. They disclose them late. They disclose them narrowly. They disclose them in a way that satisfies the letter of the law and ignores the spirit. That is not the same as hiding. It is worse, because it is legal.
The number to watch is not 61%. It is 34 days. That is how long it takes a company with a plan to tell its customers. The gap between 34 and 71 is the gap between a company that decided to speak and a company that was told to. Closing that gap is the work. The myth is just noise.
More articles