The Depot Charger Decision: Field Notes From a 38-Van EV Fleet

Archi4 min read

evscharginglogistics

Contents
  1. The 5:40 a.m. Queue
  2. What the test covered
  3. The DC case
  4. The AC case
  5. The public charger fallback
  6. The decision

The 5:40 a.m. Queue#

The first van rolled in at 5:42 a.m. with 14 percent state of charge. The depot had one borrowed 50-kW DC charger and four new 7.4-kW AC posts. The courier, a 38-van regional delivery company, was six weeks into a test that would decide how to charge the first 12 electric vans in its fleet. I was there to watch the morning handoff, not the dashboard.

The driver plugged in, walked to the dispatch window, and waited. At 6:02 a.m. the van hit 80 percent. A second van pulled into the yard at 6:04. It waited 18 minutes for the cable. By 6:20, two routes were late. That queue became the center of the decision.

What the test covered#

The company runs panel vans on routes between 70 and 160 km. The three test vans had 65-kWh packs and used 23 to 27 kWh per 100 km in mild weather. On the coldest mornings, consumption rose to 31 kWh per 100 km, mostly from cabin heat and defrost. Those numbers are from the vans' trip computers and the charger logs I reviewed with the fleet manager.

The test compared three ways to deliver roughly 360 kWh a day for 12 vans: one shared 50-kW DC charger at the depot, six 7.4-kW AC posts used overnight, and public 150-kW chargers within a 4-km detour. The company wanted one answer, not a blend. The quote for the DC unit, including trenching and a service upgrade, came in near $42,000. Six AC posts were quoted at $9,600 before wiring.

The DC case#

The DC charger was fast when it was free. A van at 18 percent reached 80 percent in 32 minutes. A van at 40 percent took 21 minutes. The problem was the clock. Most vans return between 4 and 7 p.m., and most leave between 5:30 and 6:30 a.m. A single 50-kW unit can move a lot of energy in 13 hours, but not through the same 45-minute window everyone wants.

Drivers did not queue in a neat line. They parked, plugged in, and went to finish paperwork. One van sat at 96 percent for 14 minutes while another waited. The charger's idle fee did not apply on private property, so there was no price signal to move it. The fleet manager called that the people problem. I called it the schedule.

Cold weather added friction. The DC cable stayed flexible, but the connector latch iced once. More important, prewarming the cabin before departure pulled energy that the charger had to replace. On two mornings, the first van left at 79 percent instead of 80. That was fine. The late route was not.

The AC case#

Overnight AC charging was slower and easier to live with. From 7 p.m. to 5 a.m., a 7.4-kW post adds about 74 kWh, enough for the longest route on the list even in winter. The vans sat for 10 hours anyway. The charger did not need to be fast. It needed to be available.

Six posts for 12 vans meant two waves. The company planned a 6 p.m. wave and a 9 p.m. wave. That worked until a van returned at 10:15 p.m. after a delayed delivery. It still had enough charge for the next day's 88-km route, but the margin fell to 9 percent. The fleet manager marked that as a near miss.

The AC hardware had its own small annoyances. The cable was stiff at minus 7 C. One post's holster filled with slush. Drivers sometimes left the connector on the ground. None of that stopped a charge. A DC unit would have the same cable problem and a higher repair bill.

The public charger fallback#

The public site was 4 km away and had four 150-kW stalls. In theory, a van could top up in 20 minutes. In practice, the round trip added 22 minutes and the site was full twice in eight visits. One driver waited 14 minutes for a working stall, then paid a session fee on top of the energy price. For a courier on a timed route, that was a tax on uncertainty.

The public site still had a role: backup. The company kept accounts for the vans that return late or need a midday top-up. It did not put public charging in the base plan.

The decision#

The company voted against the depot DC charger. It installed six AC posts and one 22-kW DC unit for midday top-ups, moved two routes to a 7 a.m. start, and wrote a simple rule: any van below 30 percent at 9 p.m. gets the DC unit, no debate. The AC cluster cost less than a quarter of the DC quote. The trade was schedule discipline.

On the last morning of the test, the queue was gone. The first van left at 5:55 a.m. at 92 percent. The second left at 6:03. The third left at 6:11, seven minutes later than the diesel it replaced. The fleet manager wrote the number on the whiteboard: seven minutes. That was the cost the company could live with.

More articles