The Funding Detail That Decides Term Sheets: It Is Not the Valuation
Archi5 min read
Contents
The number founders ignore until it is too late#
In startup funding, the headline number is the valuation. Founders celebrate a $20 million pre-money valuation on a $5 million raise. Investors nod. Everyone moves on. But the detail that often decides who gets what is the option pool shuffle. It is a small line in the term sheet, usually buried on page three, and it can shift millions of dollars between founders and investors.
The myth is that the option pool is a simple reserve for future hires. The fact is that the pool is often created before the investment, and it dilutes only the founders, not the investors. This is the pre-money option pool shuffle. It is standard practice in venture capital, but many first-time founders miss it.
Here is how it works. Suppose a company has 10 million shares outstanding, all owned by founders. The investor offers a $20 million pre-money valuation and a $5 million investment. The term sheet says the company must have a 10% option pool after the round. If the pool is created pre-money, the founders must carve out 10% of the post-money capitalization before the investor's money comes in. That means the founders' ownership is reduced before the investment is priced. The effective pre-money valuation is lower than $20 million.
The math that matters#
Let us run the numbers. Post-money valuation is $25 million ($20 million pre plus $5 million investment). The investor owns 20% ($5 million divided by $25 million). The option pool is 10% of the post-money capitalization, or 2.5 million shares if total post-money shares are 25 million. If the pool is pre-money, the founders must give up 2.5 million shares from their own holdings. So founders go from 10 million shares to 7.5 million shares before the investor's shares are issued. After the round, founders own 7.5 million out of 25 million shares, or 30%. The investor owns 20%, and the pool is 10%. Wait, that sums to 60%. The remaining 40%? Let me recalculate.
Actually, the total post-money shares are 25 million. Founders start with 10 million. The pool is 10% of post-money, so 2.5 million shares. The investor gets 5 million shares (20% of 25 million). That totals 17.5 million shares. The missing 7.5 million shares are the founders' original shares minus the pool? No, the founders' shares are 10 million minus the 2.5 million contributed to the pool, so 7.5 million. Then 7.5 + 2.5 + 5 = 15 million, not 25 million. The error is that the post-money shares are not simply the sum; the price per share is determined by the pre-money valuation divided by the fully diluted shares before the round, including the pool.
Let me do it properly. Pre-money valuation is $20 million. The fully diluted shares before the round include the existing 10 million plus the option pool. Let the pool be P shares. The price per share is $20 million divided by (10 million + P). The investment of $5 million buys $5 million divided by price per share. The post-money capitalization must have the pool equal to 10% of the total. So P = 0.10 * (10 million + P + new shares). New shares = $5 million / price per share = $5 million * (10 million + P) / $20 million = 0.25 * (10 million + P). So total post-money shares = 10 million + P + 0.25*(10 million + P) = 1.25*(10 million + P). And P = 0.10 * 1.25*(10 million + P) = 0.125*(10 million + P). So P = 1.25 million + 0.125P, which gives 0.875P = 1.25 million, so P = 1.4286 million shares. Total post-money shares = 1.25*(11.4286 million) = 14.2857 million. Founders own 10 million out of 14.2857 million, or 70%. Investor owns 5 million / 14.2857 million = 35%? That cannot be right because 70% + 35% > 100%. Let me check: new shares = 0.25*(11.4286 million) = 2.857 million. Total = 10 + 1.4286 + 2.857 = 14.2856 million. Founders: 10/14.2856 = 70%. Investor: 2.857/14.2856 = 20%. Pool: 1.4286/14.2856 = 10%. That sums to 100%. Good. So the founders end up with 70% instead of 80% if there were no pool. The pool cost them 10 percentage points. In dollar terms, at a $25 million post-money valuation, 10% is $2.5 million. That is the real cost of the pre-money pool.
If the pool were created post-money, the investor would bear part of the dilution. In that case, the founders would contribute only their pro rata share. The difference can be significant. In the example, the founders give up an extra 2.5% of the company compared to a post-money pool. That might not sound like much, but at exit, it can be millions.
Why investors push for it#
Investors prefer the pre-money pool because it keeps their ownership percentage intact. They are buying a slice of the company, and they do not want their slice diluted by a pool that benefits future hires. From their perspective, the pool is a cost of doing business, and the founders should bear it. This is standard in Silicon Valley term sheets, but it is not universal. Some investors, especially in Europe, may accept a post-money pool or a smaller pool.
The detail that matters is not just the size of the pool but when it is created. A 10% pool pre-money is not the same as a 10% pool post-money. Founders should negotiate both the size and the timing. A smaller pool (say, 5%) or a post-money pool can save significant dilution.
What founders can do#
First, ask for the pool to be created post-money. If the investor insists on pre-money, negotiate a smaller pool. Benchmark against similar companies: a seed-stage company might need a 5% to 10% pool, while a Series A might need 10% to 15%. But the pool should reflect actual hiring plans, not just a round number.
Second, model the dilution. Use a cap table tool or a simple spreadsheet to see how different pool sizes and timing affect your ownership. Do not rely on the headline valuation. The effective valuation is what matters.
Third, remember that the pool is not free money. It is equity that you are giving up. Every percentage point is worth something. In the example above, the pre-money pool cost the founders 10 percentage points. If they had negotiated a 5% pool, they would have saved 5 percentage points, or $1.25 million at the post-money valuation.
The myth is that the option pool is a minor detail. The fact is that it can be one of the most expensive lines in the term sheet. Founders who understand the math can save themselves a lot of pain later.
More articles